Archive for the ‘Communications’ Category

Email to IRMA

Tuesday, February 24th, 2009

Dear Sir/ Madam,

I am writing to you in relation to recent reports that you have written to Irish ISP’s requesting that they block websites that you deem to be responsible for illegal file sharing, or face court action for failing to do so.

In the public interest, I would appreciate it if you could answer the following questions for me:

  • Why does IRMA believe that it has the right to force companies independent of IRMA to censor the Internet?
  • Would it not be better for IRMA, and by extension those that it purports to represent, to educate the general public regarding the legalities of file sharing, rather than blocking the parts of the Internet it does not agree with?
  • How will IRMA compile the list of websites that it wishes to see blocked?
  • What criteria will be used to judge if a site is responsible for illegal file sharing?
  • Will IRMA require that all search engine results for search terms such as “illegal file sharing”, “p2p”, “bittorrent”, etc also be blocked?
  • Is IRMA aware that circumventing an ISP block is as simple as using a proxy server? Therefore, will IRMA also require ISP’s to block access to proxy servers?
  • Is IRMA aware of how the Bittorrent protocol works, and that .torrent files do not contain any copyrighted material?
  • Do IRMA believe that this action will achieve any other purpose then to highlight the fact that this material is available online and severely harm IRMA’s reputation?

I would appreciate a reply at your earliest convenience, and please note that I intend to publish your reply online.

Yours faithfully,
Paul McCarthy.

Lets see if I get a response.

Update

As per James’ comment I have also emailed Eamon Ryan, Minister for Communications. Below is a copy of the email I sent.

Dear Minister,

Please find enclosed a copy of an email I have sent to IRMA in relation to their request that Irish ISP’s censor the Internet on IRMA’s behalf.

As the Minister for Communications, I would appreciate it if you could make a response in relation to this situation.

I would also ask you to respond to the following questions:

  1. Do you believe that IRMA should be allowed to dictate what websites are available to the Irish public despite the fact that they are a commercial enterprise and are using Eircom’s decision to settle with the music labels to further their own commercial aims to the detriment of the Irish public?
  2. As the Minister for Communications, do you feel that IRMA’s attempts to censor the Internet to further their own commercial objectives reflects well on this country on the international stage?
  3. If IRMA is allowed to pursue this course of action, will the Irish Government stand by and allow an unelected corporate entity to decide on issues regarding free and ready access to the Internet for Irish citizens?
  4. Is the Minister aware that while the first site targeted by IRMA (thepiratebay.org) is known to facilitate illegal file sharing, that the site itself does not contain, host or provide any copyrighted material?
  5. Is the Minister concerned that IRMA are deciding on which sites to block without any oversight?

While I do not condone illegal file sharing, I do firmly believe that no commercial entity should be given a carte blanche to censor what they perceive to be a unfair competition.

If IRMA are allowed to continue in this action, then it cannot be long before other companies will use the same methods to deny the Irish Internet community access to their competitors websites.

Yours faithfully,
Paul McCarthy

Twitter Tips

Sunday, February 22nd, 2009

Tom Raferty has put together some great tips for new Twitter users. Head over and have a read. You’ll be more enlightened when you’re done.

When you’ve finished with Tom, download my latest plugin and let your blogging friends follow your Twitter Feed!

Social Networking in Ireland

Tuesday, December 30th, 2008

I’ll hold my hands up and admit that I don’t really get social networks. Maybe it’s because I’m a geek and I don’t do “normal” conversations. I get bored easily.

I’m good at listening to other people talk without being able to summon the interest to actually get involved. Though get me talking on something I’m interested in, and you won’t be able to get me to shut up – computers, the Simpsons, Star Gate, Star Trek, Terry Pratchett, rugby, snooker, good movies, WordPress, web design, Microsoft vs Apple, Internet Explorer vs Firefox ….[1]

Which all goes to show that despite the fact that I work in a bar and can, if the job requires it, talk to anybody about any subject under the sun, I still don’t do social networking all that well.[2]

Considering what I just wrote, you’ll probably find it hard to believe that I have a Bebo account,[3], a twitter account and a Facebook account. All underused and rarely checked.

Bebo annoys me. Too many kids shouting, with bad spelling and using terrible grammar.[4] Every time I see a comment left on a Bebo page, all I want to do is take a virtual red pen to it and mark the spelling and grammar mistakes.

Facebook annoys me because every time I log in there are 101 Application Invites waiting for me, and every one of them wants my personal information and requires me to invite 2,000 of my friends before I can participate. To me that’s just spamming and phishing, and I hate it. I really hate it.

Twitter on the other hand does have potential. Yes, posting is limited to 140 characters at a time, and you can’t embed images, or do anything really fancy with it, but that’s the best thing about it. It’s a simple idea, well executed. I think I may actually like Twitter. My only problem is that I don’t know enough people on Twitter to properly make use of it in a social sense.

So where is all of this going? Well, here’s where. Here’s a map of the world showing the most popular social networks within each country. The map is a bit small, so you’d think that Ireland would be hard to spot. Not so. Here’s a hint: it’s the only country coloured in red.

Social Networking Map

Social Networking Map

Notice anything else? It’s the only country in the entire world where Bebo is the dominant social networking site. To me that says two things:

  1. Considering the quality of the content on Bebo, this country’s future is fsckd[5], and
  2. Considering the age group using Bebo, I’m not the only one in my age group who doesn’t get social networking.

Now this map doesn’t give any figures, so I did a bit of digging around, and according to Alexa, 9.5% of Bebo’s traffic comes from Ireland. (In comparison, 50.5% comes from the UK and 14.9% comes from the US – figures are correct as of 30 December 2008.)

In fact Bebo ranks as Ireland’s sixth most visited website, behind Google (.ie and .com), YouTube, Yahoo and Windows Live. In other words, it’s the second most popular non-search related website in the country. That’s scary.

Facebook comes in at number seven on the list, and Twitter doesn’t even feature in the top 100.[6]

Does any of this have a point? Not really. I think it’s interesting to note that while the rest of the world is busy giving away their private data and helping to spam their friends and on-line acquaintances, we’re still at the stage of leaving “omg!!!!! u were so all over de plase last night. u goin out 4 de match 2morrow????? luv to ya cuz!!!” comments on Bebo.

Like I said, I don’t get social networking – maybe it’s because I don’t speak the language.

  1. I just read back on that list and realised that right there is a good definition of geekness. []
  2. I don’t consider blogging to be social networking, as this is usually just me talking to myself. Unless I develop a couple of separate personalities, it tends to be less than crowded around here. []
  3. Which I “donated” to my place of work []
  4. Get off my lawn! []
  5. ”LOL – OMG! u iz de bestest” – shoot me now. Please. []
  6. Maybe that explains why I like Twitter – it hasn’t been discovered by enough morons to make it a site worth avoiding []

Blog Updates Via Twitter

Monday, November 3rd, 2008

Blog updates are now available via Twitter. Just follow me here: WhatIThink on Twitter.

RTE Digital Radio Now Online

Monday, June 23rd, 2008

Via Rick O’Shea, RTE have launched their new digital radio stations online. At the moment, they’re only available in RealPlayer format – though there are links to the non-existent Windows Media streams.

The RTE “How to Listen” page also contains links to the normal broadcast radio stations and podcasts.

I’ve played around with it for a while, and although the quality isn’t bad, the connection keeps dropping with server errors – obviously there’s still a few kinks to be ironed out.

It’s a step in the right direction, but not a huge one. I’ll be much happier when I see RTE implement something along the lines of the BBC iPlayer.

Tiger Woods Nearly Brings Down The Internet

Wednesday, June 18th, 2008

I have to admit that I’m not a huge fan of golf, but even I knew that Tiger Woods was in an 18 hole play-off for the US Open with Rocco Mediate on Monday.

From about 5pm GMT, (9am local time), there was a sudden surge in Network Traffic through 70 different ISP’s in North America. Traffic peaked at about 9:30pm GMT, (1:30pm local), at a staggering 700 Gbps. That’s 500 Gbps more than usual.

Because the play-off went ahead on a Monday, most people were at work and watched the action streamed live over the Internet. The spike in traffic was so big that some engineers thought that they were witnessing a new form of DDOS, (Distributed Denial of Service), attack.

Arbor Networks have a graph of the huge traffic spike, along with a time-line of play in the US Open. They’re calling it the Tiger Effect, which would seem to be the opposite of the Slashdot Effect.

The Customisable Mobile Phone

Sunday, February 10th, 2008

I’m always on the look-out for the must have phone. Somewhere out there is the perfect phone – a phone that has the perfect balance between size, usability, components and price. I’ve trawled through sites such as Expansys.ie checking technical specs and reviews. There are a lot of great phones out there, but each and every one of them has a flaw – sometimes minor, and sometimes not.

I’ve often comes across a phone that is almost perfect only to discover that it’s missing something that I’d like or need such as wireless networking, or Bluetooth? Or it could be filled with gadgets that I don’t want such as GPS, radio and TV tuners. Sometimes the near perfect phone does come along, but it’s either unavailable where I live or it’s priced way beyond what I’m willing to pay. Two examples: the iPhone and the N95.

I suppose my problem is that a phones specs are generally fixed. They can’t be upgraded or changed, so what was top of the range six months ago, is no longer top of the range today. How much easier it would be if I could pick the required specs when buying a phone – a bit like buying a new computer. Well now I can, thanks to ZZZPhone.

ZZZPhone take an unbranded phone as a base model and allow you to add on extras. Want a 7 mega-pixel camera? No problem. How about 8GB additional memory? Done. The base model, retailing for $149, boasts an impressive list of specs: touch screen, front and rear camera, dual SIM card support, 3 mega pixel camera, 4GB memory, tri-band and so on. The full list is here. The high end add-ons cost anywhere from $7 for a water resistant case to $119 for GPS.

So now I can finally build my perfect phone. But, (there’s always a “but” isn’t there?), I don’t want one. Yes, I could pack it with as much gadgetry as I wanted, it has the ability to be everything that I want from a phone, but that’s the problem. I know that no matter how good I could make it, in six months time I’m going to be fed up with it. And I won’t be able to blame the manufacturer, just myself.

BBC iPlayer Coming to Your Mac

Thursday, February 7th, 2008

The BBC announced that they are planning to release a Mac OS version of iPlayer by the end of the year. The BBC iPlayer allows UK viewers to either download or stream the previous weeks programmes to the computer.

At the moment, the iPlayer Download Manager is a Windows only program, although the BBC states streaming service will work with any browser capable of using the latest Flash plugin. Even when it does go online, the iPlayer will only be available to users based in the UK, though there is a BBC Worldwide version of iPlayer slated for release “as soon as possible”.

The CAD$3,000 Phone Bill

Thursday, December 13th, 2007

It sounds a bit steep, but if you’ve spent a month downloading high definition movies through your mobile network, and you’re being charged per kilobyte, then it’s quite possible to rack up a bill of this size. And that’s exactly what one Canadian man did.

The thing is the bill was originally CAD$85,000. Which you have to admit is a bit steep. That’s a lot of movies downloaded. (I wonder if the next call he gets will be from the MPAA?)

In this users defence, he had signed up to a CAD$10 a month unlimited mobile browser data plan. Thing is that this plan didn’t cover data downloaded when the phone is connected to a PC and used as a modem.

Apparently, when used as a data modem, the software shows a message that extra charges will apply. So either the user missed it, or ignored it. Either way the provider is sticking to its guns in stating that the reduction to CAD$3,000 is a gesture of goodwill, and that’s as far as they’ll go.

I feel sorry for the guy, but given that he’s already been given a discount of over CAD$80,000, I can’t see him getting much more of a reduction.

Note: CAD$1 is about €0.67, so the original charge works out at about €53,000 and the reduced bill comes to about €2,000. Puts my €50 a month mobile bill in the shade.

New Phone Ordered

Sunday, August 19th, 2007

I’ve finally given up on the Samsung D900. I had thought of buying a pre-pay mobile and just swapping my SIM card, but Meteor don’t have anything that really appeals to me. So for about the same price as a pre-pay phone, I’ve ordered the Ubiquio 401 from expansys.ie.

Running on Windows Mobile 5.0 for Pocket PC, and featuring an Intel PXA212 processor, it should have a bit more punch than your standard fare mobile phone.

I’ll post a fuller review once I’ve had a chance to play around with it a bit.